The (S)catbird

It just didn’t seem fair, the way those experts dissed the catbird on a public radio program I happened upon.

I assume they were correct in saying he’s only a mimic, but isn’t it the case in song that interpreters can matter every bit as much as originators, and quite often surpass the composer in mining the music? How else would you explain, say, Ella Fitzgerald?

So, here’s what I had to say to those opinionated birders, in a poem now appearing in the Winter 2016 issue of WestWard Quarterly (print only).


The (S)catbird

Those believed to best know birdsong say

and say again the catbird lacks a song of its own

to broadcast from the crest of a winterberry tree.


In some way the critics know nature’s error of orchestration

that leaves this bird only to sample the proper sounds

of the wood thrush the magnolia warbler the red-eyed vireo

even the spring peeper, even your neighbor’s lawnmower.


In some way they know that the catbird’s mews

and whistles and squeaks, nasal moans and throaty

gurgles, count only as illegitimate borrowings from

the walls of sound that delimit his woodland home.


But we lack such certainties and, for the gift of lacking,

we still can make with innocent wonder the critical mistake

of marveling at the catbird’s discredited scatted inventions.


Leave a comment

Filed under Poetry

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s